The hidden costs of DIY Disaster Recovery

Storage pricing is not DR pricing. Hardware, bandwidth, head-count, drills, training: everything missing from your storage vendor's quote.

2 min read

TL;DR

Storage pricing is not DR pricing. An honest 3-year calculation shows that self-hosted DR costs 2-4× the planned amount once you include bandwidth, headcount, training, drills and failure management.

The line items that disappear from the quote

1. Bandwidth

Replicating 5 TB of data with 5% daily change means ~250 GB/day to the DR site. In Italy a dedicated symmetric FTTH link costs €80-200/month. Rarely counted as "DR".

2. Dedicated headcount

Even semi-automated DR needs:

  • 0.3 FTE for job supervision (one sysadmin every morning);
  • 0.2 FTE for quarterly drills;
  • 0.1 FTE for documentation and audits.

Total: 0.6 FTE = ~€30k/year in fully loaded cost. Almost never in the quote.

3. DR site hardware

Even a cold standby needs:

  • physical servers or reserved datacentre capacity;
  • replicated storage (with software licences);
  • network (switches, firewalls);
  • UPS, cooling.

Initial CAPEX for a typical SMB: €25-50k. 5-year amortisation: ~€5-10k/year.

4. Backup and replication software

Enterprise licences (Veeam, Commvault, Acronis full-tier) charge per VM or per socket. For 30 VMs, €8-15k/year in licences.

5. Staff training

A sysadmin who never executed a real DR learns it by doing it badly. Annual training (1-2 courses + time): ~€3k/year.

6. Mistakes and failed restores

The biggest "invisible cost". For every 10 drills, 2-3 fail on the first attempt, requiring iteration and fixes. Average cost of a failed drill: 4-8 person-hours + operational impact.

The real 3-year math

For an 80-employee SMB with self-hosted DR:

| Line item | Annual | 3-year | |---|---|---| | Dedicated bandwidth | €1,500 | €4,500 | | Headcount 0.6 FTE | €30,000 | €90,000 | | Amortised hardware | €8,000 | €24,000 | | Software licences | €10,000 | €30,000 | | Training | €3,000 | €9,000 | | Contingency (15%) | €7,875 | €23,625 | | Total | €60,375 | €181,125 |

The same DR in managed DRaaS (e.g. Sefthy PRO) for the same company costs about €800-1,200/month = €30-43k over 3 years. Saving: 70-80%.

Three mistakes that inflate TCO

  • buying redundant hardware without a drill plan: you are paying for an expensive cold standby;
  • relying on a single sysadmin who knows the system: when they leave, you restart from scratch;
  • not documenting runbooks: every incident becomes system rediscovery.

When self-hosted DR still makes sense

  • companies with > 500 VMs and IT teams > 10 people;
  • total air-gap requirements for national security;
  • sectoral compliance forbidding cloud (rare).

FAQ

Where is the break-even between DRaaS and self-hosted?

Typically around 150-250 VMs for Italian companies. Below, DRaaS is almost always cheaper. Above, it depends on existing IT team.

Are 0.6 FTE unavoidable?

In DRaaS they drop to 0.1-0.2 FTE because the provider handles job supervision and infrastructure.

Should I keep on-prem licences alongside DRaaS?

No. You pay twice. Migrate fully or stay on-prem.


For the cloud vs on-prem comparison, read Cloud DR vs on-prem DR. For realistic BCDR pricing, BCDR pricing for MSPs.

Want to see Sefthy in action?

Same IP, same subnet, RTO in minutes. Try it free for 7 days or talk to one of our specialists.

In the press

Remote support

Download Sefthy Assist and run it. A Sefthy technician will see your screen and help you.

We answer Monday to Friday, 9 am to 6 pm Italian time. Outside these hours your request stays in the queue and we get back to you.

Only Sefthy technicians can connect, you can end the session whenever you want and nothing stays installed on your computer.

For any question write to us at [email protected].

Sefthy will never ask you to download this program through a call or an email you were not expecting.